• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Brother's Fish House Arcadia - Fresh, Homemade Seafood and Welcoming Family Dining

Brother's Fish House Arcadia is a cozy, family-owned seafood gem in Arcadia, Florida, known for its fresh, scratch-made dishes and warm hospitality. Highlights include their acclaimed clam chowder, crispy coconut shrimp, and flavorful seafood pasta—each crafted with homemade sauces and sides like ranch and coleslaw. While the small, clean space gets busy, the attentive, friendly service shines through, reflecting true care and pride. Though tucked away in an unassuming strip center, the inviting atmosphere and exceptional flavors make it a must-visit for seafood lovers seeking authentic, heartfelt meals in a welcoming setting.

Brother's Fish House Arcadia at a glance

  • Address 5 N Luther Ave, Arcadia, FL 34266, United States
  • Phone +1 863-722-0185
  • Restaurant type Restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

Brother's Fish House Arcadia: Reviews & Ratings

Kristi Scudera
5

First and most important, the food is amazing! The homemade ranch, the homemade Cole slaw, every entree with the homemade sauces… just fabulous! I’ve eaten there twice this past week alone! The service, everyone is super nice. They’re attentive, just a tad slow. But, it’s because it’s a very small place and it gets busy so I understand that. Atmosphere is just an ok for me. I only dislike that the bathroom is so close to the dining area. One person blowing it up and it’ll ruin your meal. But, until that happens, I love this place!

Debbie Schwind
5

My new favorite place in Arcadia. Great selection of seafood. All cooked fresh and comes out hot. Great staff. I am already looking forward to the next time.

Ray Newberry Well Drilling
5

Our family has visited this restaurant several times since its opening. The food is great the atmosphere is welcoming and comfortable and the service is courteous. They have the best clam chowder I have ever eaten at a restaurant! It is family owned and operated and you can tell by the level of personal service you receive. If you are looking for good food and a quiet atmosphere do not hesitate to check it out.

Mark Simpson
5

We had chowder, coconut shrimp, seafood pasta, and flan. All of the food was from scratch and delicious. The service is knowledgeable and friendly. The restaurant is located in a small, unattractive strip center and it is a little hard to spot because the signage is not great. However, the restaurant interior looks relatively new and it is very clean. I will be back.

Sandra Thompson
5

Great food and customer service. Coconut shrimp, fried oysters, and grilled crab cake were all delicious. Highly recommend.

Margot Ayre
5

I had the 2 piece fish & chips and it was done to perfection! The portion was enough for 2 people! I highly recommend you try it, if you haven't already!

MASeahawk
5

Our first visit and it won’t be our last. The restaurant is spotless. Even the sauce bottles are clean. The wait staff is personable and efficient. Fish and shrimp were delicious- hot, fresh and crisp. Looking forward to trying more things on the menu.

Tara Mofford
5

Food and service were both fantastic. I had the fish and chips. My daughter had clam strips. Soo delicious! Flan for desert was icing on the cake. We will be back

Location

  • Brother's Fish House Arcadia
    Brother's Fish House Arcadia
    5 N Luther Ave, Arcadia, FL 34266, United States Hotline: +1 863-722-0185

Brother's Fish House Arcadia is a hidden seafood gem nestled in the heart of Arcadia, Florida. Though tucked away in a modest strip center, this family-owned restaurant delivers an impressive culinary experience that truly stands out. Upon entering, you’re greeted by a clean, inviting interior that sets the tone for a cozy meal centered around fresh, carefully prepared seafood dishes.

The standout here is the commitment to homemade flavors—from the creamy house-made ranch and tangy coleslaw to the rich, scratch-made sauces that uplift every entree. Whether it’s the clam chowder, hailed by patrons as the best they've ever tasted, or the crispy coconut shrimp and perfectly grilled crab cakes, each dish reflects deep care and culinary expertise. The seafood pasta is another highlight, weaving together fresh ingredients into a harmonious, flavorful plate.

Service is friendly and attentive, embodying the warmth of a family-run business. While the establishment’s intimate size can lead to slower service during busy times, this only adds to the authenticity and personal touch that guests appreciate. The atmosphere strikes a balance—comfortable and welcoming—though the proximity of the restroom to the dining area can be a minor distraction.

Overall, Brother's Fish House Arcadia shines through its dedication to quality ingredients, homemade recipes, and heartfelt service. For lovers of fresh, thoughtfully crafted seafood in a relaxed setting, this spot is well worth the visit.

Business Information

  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery